Restoring ability to remove zombie cells may keep us sharp as we age

Transmission electron micrograph of human neutrophils, immune cells that can turn rogue with age
Transmission electron micrograph of human neutrophils, immune cells that can turn rogue with age
ROSSANA MELO/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY

As we age, our body loses its ability to clear out zombie-like cells that have stopped dividing, instead dripping out poison and turning other cells rogue. Restoring the ability to remove these “senescent” cells prevented signs of cognitive decline and frailty in older mice, with hints that the same outcomes could occur in people.

“What’s attractive about this study is that it is not trying to kill [senescent] cells directly,” says Derek Gilroy at University College London, who wasn’t involved in the research. “It is repairing the body’s own waste-disposal system that should have removed them in the first place.”

To better understand why this system goes awry, Katrin Andreasson at Stanford University, California, and her colleagues compared mice aged 6 to 8 months (roughly equivalent to people in their 20s) with mice aged 23 to 25 months (equivalent to people in their late 60s or 70s). They found that the older mice had more of these senescent cells in their organs, including the liver and spleen, as well as in their bone marrow.

Specifically, the senescent cells were neutrophils, immune cells that are normally the body’s first line of defence against infection. These would normally be cleared away by macrophages residing in tissue, which remove damaged cells and debris, but this ability declines with age.

Andreasson and her colleagues traced this decline to prostaglandin E2, a signalling molecule that increases with age. They found that higher prostaglandin E2 activity overstimulates a receptor called EP2 on tissue-resident macrophages, which leaves them less able to remove senescent cells.

Next, the team tested whether blocking this overstimulation could improve signs of ageing by genetically modifying the EP2 gene from tissue-resident macrophages in older mice. These animals went on to clear more senescent neutrophils and showed signs of healthier ageing, including lower levels of inflammation, reduced muscle loss, less visceral fat and better mobility, compared with unmodified mice of the same age. They also performed almost as well as young mice in memory tests. “We were very surprised at the magnitude of the effect,” says Andreasson.

The researchers also tested an experimental drug that blocks EP2. When given orally to older mice for two months, this caused similar age-related improvements to those experienced by the genetically modified mice.

“This is a very promising study, but we need to be careful,” says Gilroy. “EP2 is part of a normal signalling system, and blocking it throughout the body could have unwanted effects.” The mice experienced no known side effects, but Gilroy says it may be safer to target EP2 in ageing macrophages specifically.

Finally, the team found similar patterns in human tissue, with liver samples from older people showing higher EP2 activity and more senescent neutrophils. “The human data are supportive, but still correlative,” says Gilroy. “We haven’t yet shown that blocking EP2 can restore neutrophil clearance in aged human tissue.” 

The researchers are now planning to study whether this process affects the onset of conditions such as Alzheimer’s disease.

Journal Reference:

Science DOI: 10.1126/science.aei9816

Best treatment for multiple sclerosis may be antivirals

A scanning electron micrograph of immune cells called microglial cells (round) ingesting specialised cells called oligodendrocytes (branched) that maintain the myelin sheath around nerves, which is thought to occur in multiple sclerosis
Microglial immune cells (round) ingesting specialised cells called oligodendrocytes (branched) that maintain the myelin sheaths around nerves. This process is thought to occur in multiple sclerosis
Science Photo Library

The best treatment for multiple sclerosis (MS) might be antivirals that target the Epstein-Barr virus. Pharmaceutical companies are now being called on to develop such drugs after researchers studied the immune responses of people with and without the condition.

“There aren’t good Epstein-Barr virus drugs currently available, but they can be developed,” says Michael Levy at Harvard Medical School. “That might be the most useful specific therapy for MS in the future.”

MS is caused by an immune attack on myelin, a fatty sleeve that wraps around nerves. The loss of myelin reduces their ability to transmit signals and can cause a wide range of symptoms, including muscle weakness. Drugs that suppress the immune system can slow the progression of the condition.

There is strong evidence that the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), which causes mononucleosis, or glandular fever, is also the cause of MS. “I think most MS researchers now would agree that EBV plays a major role in the development of the disease,” says team member Kjetil Bjornevik at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

But exactly how remains a mystery. Almost everyone is infected with EBV during their childhood or teen years. It mainly infects immune cells known as B-cells, where it can remain dormant for the rest of a person’s life. But in some cells, the virus can reactivate.

The big question is why only around 1 in 1000 people develop MS when nearly everyone gets EBV. This suggests there is something different about the immune response to EBV in people who go on to develop MS, says team member Natalia Drosu at Massachusetts General Hospital. “Our question for this study was: in people with MS, what parts of EBV does the immune system respond to? And do those responses look different from people who don’t have MS?”

The team focused on immune cells known as CD4 T-cells, which circulate in the body. Although these aren’t the cells that directly attack myelin, there are multiple lines of evidence suggesting they play a role in MS, says Drosu.

The team found that, in 30 people with MS, most of the CD4 T-cells targeting EBV were specifically targeting viral proteins produced when the virus is actively replicating, rather than the proteins associated with its dormant stage. What’s more, people with MS produced twice as many of these cells, on average, as 30 people without the condition.

The researchers then looked at T-cells in 60 people with MS before and after they began drug treatments that reduce their number of B-cells. They found these treatments reduced the T-cell response to EBV almost to the levels seen in people without MS.

In addition, the team found low levels of EBV in the saliva of these people before they were treated to reduce their number of B-cells, which shows that the virus was replicating in their bodies. After treatment, viral levels dropped below detectable levels in most people.

The thinking has been that B-cells help drive the harmful immune response in people with MS, says Levy, and this is why drugs that reduce B-cell levels are effective. But the results suggest these drugs also work by eliminating B-cells infected with EBV, he says, thereby reducing the immune response caused by active viral replication. “We’re thinking that depleting B-cells is also depleting the reservoir of the Epstein-Barr virus.”

If so, targeting EBV directly with antivirals might be just as effective as B-cell-depleting drugs, but without the undesirable side effects of treatments that weaken the immune system, such as an increased risk of infections. “I think a lot of patients would prefer a specific drug,” says Bjornevik. “If we can show that an antiviral had a similar effect as the most effective MS drugs, I think there will be a big market for that drug.”

Another approach already being trialled for treating MS is using modified immune cells called CAR T-cells. While existing drugs merely reduce B-cell levels, CAR T-cells can temporarily eliminate them altogether. Dozens of people with MS have gone into remission after CAR-T treatment, says Levy.

But EBV might linger in some other cell types and reinfect B-cells as they slowly recover in the years after the CAR T-cell treatment, he says. “Then we would need the antivirals… so we just have to wait and see.” CAR T-cells can also have serious side effects, says Bjornevik, so antivirals could be safer as well.

There are also vaccines against EBV under development. “If people don’t get infected with EBV, their risk of MS would be virtually zero,” says Drosu. “So I think vaccines are [a] very promising strategy to eradicate MS.”

But 1000 people would have to be vaccinated to prevent just one case of MS, Levy points out, so it isn’t clear if EBV would be justified for preventing MS alone. However, EBV causes many other problems, including a number of cancers, and has also been linked to other autoimmune conditions, such as lupus and rheumatoid arthritis.  

Journal reference:

Science Translational Medicine DOI: 10.1126/scitranslmed.adz6566

Game that reduces dementia risk may clear amyloid from men’s brains

Beta-amyloid forms plaques in the brain (seen in yellow) that play a role in Alzheimer’s disease
JUAN GAERTNER/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY/Alamy

A cognitive “speed training” game that cuts dementia risk by 25 per cent alters levels of beta-amyloid, a protein that clogs up the brain in Alzheimer’s disease, in men, but not in women.

It is the first time brain training has been shown to influence the levels of a neurodegenerative marker, strengthening the evidence suggesting that mental exercises can boost brain health.

“One of the main markers that’s indicative of future dementia risk got better for men who completed cognitive speed training,” says Hye Won Chai at Clemson University in South Carolina, who presented the research at the Alzheimer’s Association International Conference in London on 12 July.

The computer-based speed training involves recalling where objects have flashed up, with the task becoming harder as performance improves. A prior 20-year study by some of Chai’s colleagues showed that people aged 65 and older, who did the training were 25 per cent less likely to be diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease or a related form of dementia compared with a control group.

In the latest study, Chai and her team recruited a separate group of 53 people from the US aged 65 and older, 13 of whom were male. About a third of the participants were asked to complete between 2 and 4 hours of speed training each week for 4.5 months.

The remaining participants were either told to spend the same amount of time playing games such as Solitaire, word search and a game similar to Connect 4, or to complete another kind of brain training in which they had to strategically track objects and switch between tasks.

To explore how speed training may reduce dementia risk, the team collected blood samples from all of the participants at the start and end of the training period.

This revealed that, among men, speed training increased the ratio of two forms of beta-amyloid found in the blood, which suggests the training boosted the brain’s ability to clear beta-amyloid 42. This protein forms clumps called plaques in the brain during Alzheimer’s disease, disrupting brain function. The other two kinds of training had no effect.

“It’s a really cool finding,” says Sasha Novozhilova at McGill University in Montreal. “It is definitely strengthening what they’ve [previously] shown with the reduction in dementia.”

Some Alzheimer’s treatments, such as lecanemab, have been designed to help clear amyloid from the brain, but they only marginally slow cognitive decline during Alzheimer’s disease. The limited benefit seen in trials is probably down to these treatments being taken at a relatively late stage of the condition, when substantial brain damage has already occurred, says Andrea Castegnaro at University College London.

Engaging in cognitive training to reduce beta-amyloid build-up before dementia develops may have a bigger effect on dementia because it would be done before much brain damage has occurred, says Castegnaro.

However, cognitive training had no effect on amyloid levels in female participants in the study. This suggests that speed training reduces dementia risk in different ways in women and men, says Chai.

The team hopes to explore how speed training may benefit women in future studies, says Chai. But first, the findings need to be verified in geographically and ethnically diverse groups, says Novozhilova.